Skip to Content

Shadow Treasurer’s Address to ASFA Conference, Melbourne

Copy LinkPrintEmailFacebookTwitter

Thank you for that incredibly kind introduction. No, though shyness does not come naturally to me, I will accept that fate. But it's wonderful to be here at ASFA and to be chatting to you all about the importance of superannuation, the role and the contribution you play within the Australian economy and in the future.

I'm not one who automatically races to achieve bipartisan outcomes, because I believe that often that's when Canberra conspires against its citizens. What we actually want is to make sure we have the right policy settings to advance the national interest, to improve the livelihoods and empower Australians to live their best lives.

But I know that the topic of the Superannuation Guarantee and its role in an alternative government led by Angus Taylor is a topic that will sit on some people's minds. And of course, I also know that yesterday the Treasurer did what he so often likes to do, which is to come and run political lines to achieve a political objective without fully accepting or understanding the consequences of doing it. Because if you want to have a bipartisan system focused on superannuation that belongs to all Australians, it's probably best not to use it as a political football. But that is not currently where the debate sits.

Yesterday, of course, he spoke specifically about the idea that an alternative government or other political parties are setting out to, whatever his phrase is today, “destroy super,” etc. So, let's just be very direct and very blunt about how we would approach super, because there are various pronouncements out there and I want to remove all doubt.

Under a Coalition government, the Superannuation Guarantee will be guaranteed. That is not my focus or interest in the sector. That's a “full stop, that’s it” kind of commitment.

I want to have a very different conversation about super and the importance of making sure that it advances the national interest, and of course, more importantly, advances the best interests of Australians. Because at the end of the day, super money is, of course, the money of Australians for their retirement. But it's part of a package of what's necessary for Australians to live a dignified retirement.

That simple proposition, that it’s Australians' money that should be used for a dignified retirement, is central to how I approach it. But it's also not an urn of grandma's ashes that sits on the top shelf never to be touched. Superannuation is part of the financial structure that's used to live a dignified life in working life and in retirement. And of course, we have to make sure that it's put towards good purpose. Because money in superannuation is income that is deferred into the future. It's given a preferential tax treatment, but it is still Australians' money. They own it, whether it's self-managed or in an industry fund or a retail fund.

I believe, and I've believed for a long time, and since my, let's say, challenging days, perhaps controversial, chairing the House Economics Committee, that the financial system exists to serve its customers and not the other way around. Because superannuation is the members' money, not the funds' money, not the unions' money, not the government's money. It's not a national asset. It is Australians' money. I think that should be pretty clear for everybody.

And Australians are sick of the laws around superannuation constantly changing in response to governments needing to raise revenue, or of course, that leading to higher costs and them having to have their own financial security over the long term disrupted. And of course, we've had a number of those proposals in recent years. It took the Opposition, and of course community pressure, to force the government to abandon its tax on unrealised capital gains, which would have been a disaster in added complexity for the superannuation industry, but also directly undermined confidence in investing in superannuation and the long-term advancement of fund members.

Because the retirement system has three core pillars: home ownership is the foundation of economic security, superannuation for income, and the pension, of course, as a fallback. The most important of these three is home ownership, and its absence leads to higher and rising costs in retirement, and it's the biggest indicator of poverty in retirement. Home ownership is not just about bricks and mortar, it's about the spiritual centre of families, the North Star of our aspiration, and the economic security of tomorrow.

That is why I have always argued that we need to make sure we have people making financial decisions based on a hierarchy of their best interests, or home first, super second. Because young Australians can buy earlier and cheaper, save on rent, and maximise the time that they live without a mortgage. Prioritising income in retirement over home ownership, or super first and home second, lacks economic and human logic. Those in the super industry who won't accept this foundational truth, I think, compromise the very credibility of the system in my eyes. Because it is simply a proposition of logic: almost everybody I know who says that superannuation is more a priority than home ownership normally owns their own home.

I believe very strongly that we must make this a central pillar and a national priority. And it should not be hard to say that we do not want a nation of retired renters, as my colleague Senator Andrew Bragg regularly points out. Because the average first home buyer is now in their mid to late 30s. With 30-year mortgages, we are now seeing more and more Australians using super for a home. The only question is whether they bring home ownership forward through a deposit or merely to clear the remaining debt at retirement. It's obvious that the best outcome for Australians is that they can buy their home earlier and cheaper for their working life and for their retirement.

But that does not mean super should be used flippantly. As I outlined in the Parliament last month, when One Nation tried to amend a piece of legislation to include its drawdown proposition and use super like an ATM as a way to soften the impact of inflation, we opposed it, because it basically lets the Treasurer off the hook. Australians are doing it tough because of inflation caused by a government spending addiction. The Reserve Bank has been forced to raise interest rates 17 times, and of course five times this year. Prices are up by 18.3% since this government came to power.

Taking money out of super won't be any good for the people who withdraw it, and it will make it even harder for all Australians just to get ahead. They're going to pay more and get less whether they have access to their super or not. And inflation doesn't hit anybody specifically; it hits everybody. The only solution to kick inflation is, of course, to remove the government's economic model, which stokes inflation, taxes inflation, and spends inflation in a vicious cycle that is making Australians poorer. And One Nation's plan would have perpetuated that model and its active inflation agenda.

The Coalition has already found $31 billion in savings, and of course, everyone is fully costed by the Parliamentary Budget Office, to take the pressure off inflation and interest rates. That is central to make sure that Australians can retire with dignity, because everybody is impacted by the consequences of inflation.

And of course, that brings me to how we will approach super.

First, as I've said already, super is Australians' money, not a national asset. And yesterday, the Treasurer described it as the fourth-biggest capital pool in the world. But it is not a national asset that the government can use and use it as it sees fit. It's people's money, and it should be within their control. The central pillar around super must be choice and control, reflect the role it plays, and of course, the concessions are there for a reason.

Choice is not just about the choice of fund, though that is, of course, an important part of the conversation. Australians have the right to choose their fund, to switch their fund, and of course, to hold their fund accountable. And I believe very strongly that super fund members must be able to hold their fund accountable. And we're currently exploring different ways to make it easier for Australians to do just that.

We're also pursuing different ways to look at how we can empower Australians to run their own superannuation fund, because a competitive market should provide investment choice. And what we need to do is maximise choice and control. That is not against workers choosing a bigger fund or people outside of a big fund investing in different types of funds. Of course, the more flexibility, and the more competition and choice, and of course, the more product innovation occurs, the more people who have their own self-managed fund should be able to invest in different types of funds as they see fit.

But the Productivity Commission has found engagement is low, and the highest among those are those with high balances or, of course, those nearing retirement. I want Australians to own their super. I want them to see their super. I want them to feel their super and use it as a vehicle as part of their financial planning and actually to improve their financial literacy.

Secondly, we must ensure that super achieves performance. Australians need to know their savings are being protected. And more than 11,000 Australians, of course, put around a billion dollars of their retirement savings into Shield and First Guardian before they collapsed, and those Australians deserve answers and accountability, and an effective response.

But I'm also very strongly of the view that we need to make sure super funds are investing strongly in their back-end systems and particularly around issues of cybersecurity. While I know a lot of the sector boasts about its fee schedule as a pathway of its marketing strategy, one of the deep-seated concerns I have is that in a rising environment, not just about artificial intelligence, but also across increasing cyberattacks, that there is proper security around Australians' retirement savings. Because nothing will send Australians into greater panic than when they check their balance of their account, whether it's a retail bank or a super fund, that they see their money is no longer there. So, I expect a very high level of due diligence on the importance of cybersecurity, and certainly I'm glad that APRA will be prioritising this even more, and I know they already are.

Of course, I'm automatically not against discussion about the efficacy of the existing performance test, but I do have concerns, very deep concerns, about what the Treasurer has announced yesterday. Because what I see is a new benchmark set at a margin above inflation for up to 5% of a fund's portfolio, and that, of course, that he'll let it become a vehicle to let capital flow into startups, housing and energy, and he put a figure of around $90 billion of it. But this is a government that admits in its own budget its new taxes will lead to worse outcomes. And I am not convinced that these proposals are actually going to advance the national interest or, of course, members' interests.

Because what we are seeing is the government using Australians' superannuation to plug its economic potholes. It's probably apt that this conference, in that light, is in Victoria. Because the reality is, when you're talking about the government failing to make investments in renewable energy attractive, they're now raiding Australians' superannuation to fill their economic pothole. When we're talking about the higher taxes that they introduced in the Federal Budget, which has directly undermined investment in venture capital and growing businesses, they have created another economic pothole. And their answer is to use Australians' retirement savings to fill those economic potholes.

What we want is, of course, the best returns for members, to have choice and control, and to make sure that Australians are investing because they see those investments align with their long-term financial security in their working life and in their retirement.

So, there are clearly big choices that need to be made around super, and the Treasurer has opened the discussion. And there are two paths from here. One is the path we are on, with higher taxes on savings and aspiration, persistent home-grown inflation, falling living standards, and a financial system where the government decides what you may do with your own money. That path ends with a nation of retired renters, and no size of a super balance will solve that problem.

The other is to build a nation of ownership: ownership of homes, ownership of super, and of course, ownership of your future. Because control and choice go to the central pillar, which is whether you are in command of your own destiny. And that is the focus we are going to bring.

We will repeal the taxes, of course, that Australians didn't vote for, and impose discipline on spending so interest rates can fall, and of course, inflation doesn't destroy incomes in retirement. And we'll maintain an unshakable commitment to the principle that it is your money, your savings, your future, and your right to decide how to use your superannuation. It's a country where young Australians buy their own home earlier and cheaper, and own their super, and approach retirement with confidence rather than with fear.

Because every retirement contribution is a promise that is made by our present selves to our future selves. And super is ultimately Australians' money. They should be able to use it to live a dignified life in their working life and in their retirement to support themselves and their families. Because I want an Australia where young Australians can look to the horizon with confidence, with a belief in themselves, and that their hard work will pay off, Australians are in control of their lives, and they feel a basic sense of respect and show respect to each other.

And that's the basis on which we will approach superannuation. Thank you.

Back to top