Skip to Content

Albanese Government hits small business with 130,000 automated super letters while big business gets 119

Copy LinkPrintEmailFacebookTwitter

“The Albanese government is targeting small business because it needs revenue to feed its spending addiction by firing more than 150,000 automated letters without any evidence of a breach of the law”, said Shadow Treasurer Tim Wilson.

Mr Wilson’s comments come in the wake of the ATO confirming in writing to the Shadow Treasurer that 150,947 automated superannuation guarantee letters have been issued since 1 July 2025. Of those, 132,547 went to micro businesses turning over less than $2 million, and just 119 went to large businesses.

“For every letter the ATO sent to a big business, it sent more than 1,100 to a micro business. Big business has teams of lawyers and accountants to argue with the taxman. The corner store has the owner, a laptop and a Sunday night”, Mr Wilson said.

“The operating model of the Albanese government is to accuse first, check never”. 

“The ATO included threats of 200 per cent penalties in these letters, while also admitting it can’t confirm any wrongdoing. That means thousands of honest small business owners are being bullied by the Albanese government for allegations they can’t prove”.

“The Treasurer must pause these letters until the ATO can prove its data is right and show every business the evidence it relies on, or honest small businesses will pay for errors they didn’t make, and some won’t survive to prove their innocence”.

Mr Wilson said, “Australia needs a stand-up economy, not a sit-down economy, where small businesses are backed, not billed. That’s why the Coalition is standing with small business and consulting on a Small Business Act that makes Canberra count the cost before it hands down decisions like this”.

BACKGROUND

How the letters work

The ATO has been sending small businesses automated “nudge letters” since September 2024. They cross-match Single Touch Payroll data reported by employers against contributions data reported by super funds. Where the two don’t line up, the ATO tells the business its data shows it may not have met its superannuation guarantee obligations.

The letters reach back as far as the July to September 2021 quarter. They tell employers to review their records, correct their reporting or lodge an SG statement, and they warn of penalties of up to 200 per cent plus interest charges if the ATO later finds a shortfall at audit. One letter seen by the Coalition listed 19 quarters of alleged shortfalls.

What the Coalition has already raised

On 27 October 2026, Shadow Treasurer Tim Wilson raised concerns ahead of Senate Estimates. He warned that the letters assume guilt, reverse the onus of proof and threaten penalties without evidence of wrongdoing. The concerns were reported in The Australian.

The Institute of Certified Bookkeepers has warned that letters name no employees, identify no funds and give no payment dates. That means an employer who paid everyone and an employer who paid no one can receive the same letter.

The ATO’s own guidance admits that a mismatched ABN can raise a false flag, and that inconsistent data means it may contact employers unnecessarily. In many cases the gap is a rounding error or a delay at a super fund clearing house, not a failure by the business.

On 23 October 2026, Mr Wilson wrote to the Commissioner of Taxation seeking the number of letters issued, the total shortfall alleged, the accuracy testing done, and whether compliant businesses would have the letter left on their record.

What the ATO has now admitted

On 6 November 2026, ATO Deputy Commissioner Ben Kelly replied on the Commissioner’s behalf. The ATO confirmed:

  • 150,947 letters have been issued since 1 July 2025, alleging $5.4 billion in potential unpaid super.
  • It does not make any findings on how many recipients were actually compliant.
  • Around 300 employers were sent letters despite having no unpaid super, only late payments. The ATO has since “adjusted” its parameters.
  • Some letters don’t name the employees involved. Those businesses are told to review their own payroll and banking records and call the Superannuation Infoline.
  • Every letter is recorded on the employer’s file, including where the business is shown to have complied.
  • The threat of penalties is included deliberately, because in the ATO’s experience taxpayers may disregard letters that omit or downplay consequences.
  • It is now changing future letters so they don’t give “unnecessary concern to compliant taxpayers”.
  • Before scaling up the campaign, the scheme was tested with only a small pilot in 2024, plus a further pilot in 2025.
  • $467 million was disclosed by employers after 97,800 letters in 2025-26. The ATO has not said how many of the remaining letters were wrong.

DATA

Letters by employer size

Employer sizeLettersShare
Micro (<$2m turnover)132,54787.8%
SME ($2m - $250m turnover)17,29011.5%
Large (>$250m turnover)1190.08%
Unknown9910.7%
Total150,947

Letters by state

StateLetters
New South Wales61,945
Victoria37,896
Queensland27,844
Western Australia10,853
South Australia6,920
Australian Capital Territory2,425
Tasmania1,954
Northern Territory1,100
Back to top